We have built up an impressive list of monthly flavors over our lifetime. All of the flavors below have appeared in our cases at least once, and may appear again sometime soon… Or if you’d rather not wait, you can always custom order a dozen or more any time of the year, at least a week in advance.
Apple Walnut
A maple walnut cupcake with apple pie filling, topped with cream cheese icing and finished with a dollop of apple pie filling and crushed walnuts.
Banana Pudding
A banana cupcake with banana pudding filling, topped with vanilla butter cream and finished with a dollop of banana pudding and a vanilla wafer.
Boston Cream
2 yellow cupcakes with vanilla pudding filling and finished with chocolate buttercream.
Brownie Mint
A brownie topped with a mint cupcake, topped with green mint cream cheese icing and finished with mini chocolate chips.
Candy Corn Cupcake
A festive vanilla cupcake with orange and yellow sprinkles baked in, iced with orange buttercream, topped with candy corn and sprinkles, and filled with Brach's Candy Corn.
Dark Chocolate Raspberry
A dark chocolate raspberry cake iced with raspberry cream cheese frosting and then topped off with a raspberry candy piece.
Dirt Cupcake
Chocolate cupcake with Oreo pudding filling, vanilla buttercream, and a gummy worm with Oreo crumble "dirt."
French Toast
A cinnamon cupcake with bacon pieces, brown sugar cream cheese icing, and cinnamon sugar, topped with bacon pieces, and finished with a maple syrup drizzle.
Peach Poundcake
A peach poundcake topped with a peach glaze.
Peanut Butter Oreo
A cupcake made with peanut butter oreos, filled with peanut butter and crushed oreo cookies, iced in rich peanut butter and decadent chocolate buttercreams, and drizzled with peanut butter before being topped with even more oreo pieces.
Pumpkin Pie
A pumpkin cupcake with a pumpkin pie filling baked in, topped with cream cheese icing and finished with a sprinkle of pumpkin pie spice.
S'Mores
A chocolate cupcake filled with a marshmallow graham cracker mixture, topped with marshmallow buttercream and finished with a 1/4 Hershey's chocolate piece and graham cracker crumbs.
Skittles
A vanilla cupcake filled with skittles candy, topped with vanilla butter cream swirled with sprinkles and finished with a skittles candy piece.
Snickers
A chocolate cupcake with peanut butter chips, topped with vanilla buttercream and finished with a piece of a Snickers candy bar.